Consultation context
During the consultation (which set out to capture the views of parents, carers, teachers, students, HE providers and employers) it was proposed that teachers would make the final decision on students’ exam grades. Grades would be guided by students’ performances to date, mocks and tests, but based only upon topics that students have been taught rather than the whole curriculum, if it hasn’t been covered. This recommendation was supported by over 85% of respondents1 and, overall, I’m in favour of this approach. Having taught in a secondary school myself, I consider teachers to be best placed to judge their students’ understanding and progress within a subject. However, I do appreciate that this line of attack may not suit everyone and could put considerable, additional pressure onto teachers.
Schools will be provided with a package of support materials by exam boards and hopefully this will be a useful guide for teachers and aid in grading decisions. The fact that there is flexibility surrounding the use of these materials too, such as suggested exam questions, advice about content coverage, topic selection, marking and grading judgements, should go some way towards easing the angst that some teachers may face. At the time of writing this article, the final guidance on support materials has not yet been published, but should be available here shortly as the consultation is currently being analysed.